Too often Eamonn Dunphy spews nonsense from his comfortable chair in the RTE studio. Presumably God has graced us with his presence to deflate the Irish nation. It is his favourite pastime.
But on this occasion, Dunphy had a point. Watching Ireland was depressing last night. LetÃ¢â‚¬â„¢s not be fooled by the result. There is still a lot of improvement needed by the men in green.
At times last night it seemed Cyprus were the team ranked 38 while TrapattoniÃ¢â‚¬â„¢s men ranked 76 in the World.
The Cypriots were intent on playing football. Ireland resorted to long, hopeless balls into Robbie Keane and Kevin Doyle. The pair was devoid of any service all night.
During the first quarter of an hour, things seemed rosy for Ireland. The demons of the ‘Nicosia Horror Show’ back in October 2006 were soon banished when Kevin Doyle opened the scoring.
Stephen Hunt fired a corner in. Sean St. Ledger and Keith Andrews ensured the ball remained in the home sideÃ¢â‚¬â„¢s box. The ensuing scuffle resulted in the ball finding Doyle who pivoted and fired past Avgousti.
The Irish held a narrow one goal advantage. The early advantage should have seen Ireland grow in confidence and them put the game beyond the Cypriots.
Instead the midfield went missing. Ireland surrendered possession needlessly. Their ball retention was extinct.
Keith Andrews and Glenn Whelan arenÃ¢â‚¬â„¢t good enough in midfield. Both show credible determination. Both are tenacious.Ã‚Â Neither are creative.
Ireland misses a link between the forwards and midfield. The return of Steven Reid will be welcomed by all, if he ever returns. A new slimline Andy Reid deserves a chance.
Cyprus pressure paid off on the half hour mark. A great tackle by Richard Dunne was rendered pointless when moment later the ball fell to Ilia who rifled a shot past Shay Given in goal.
Ã¢â‚¬Å“The choice of Hunt tonight ahead over McGeady was very telling. He [Trapattoni] prefers in your face aggression which Hunt gives you, to technical ability and the danger McGeady posesÃ¢â‚¬Â.
Another valid point made by Dunphy. The arrival of the Celtic winger signalled the ItalianÃ¢â‚¬â„¢s intent. Victory was a must with Italy and Bulgaria winning.
The pace of McGeady proposed a different threat to the home sides defence. Caleb Folan replaced Kevin Doyle as Ireland looked to deploy the Ã¢â‚¬Å“root oneÃ¢â‚¬Â tactic more effectively.
Yet it was two stalwarts of this Irish team that rescued all three points on the night. Robbie Keane and Damien Duff combined to snatch a 2-1 victory.
It was a temporary flash back to the glory days of the Mick McCarthy Saipan era when the Irish squad was brimming with talent and the duo of Keane and Duff were at the height of their powers.
A right footed cross by Duff tempted Avgousti off his line. Keane leaped ahead of the keeperÃ¢â‚¬â„¢s outstretched fists and nodded into the empty net.
The Irish dug in and saw out the remaining eight minutes.
What does this mean for Group 8?
Italy remain in pole position with 17 points, Ireland are just behind on 16 points while Bulgaria are third on 12 points. Both Italy and Bulgaria have a game in hand over the Irish, albeit against each other.
The tie against the Italians at Croke Park on October the 10th will be crucial. The Azzuri wonÃ¢â‚¬â„¢t be fazed by an Irish side branded as Ã¢â‚¬Å“modest, without ideas, slow and predictableÃ¢â‚¬Â.
As a spectator that night in Bari it is a fair assessment by the Italians of an average Irish side which failed to penetrate the Cannavaro and company despite a one man advantage.
Yet regardless of the teamÃ¢â‚¬â„¢s flaws, Trapattoni deserves credit. Most Irish fans will admit that the manager is working with a limited side.
He has reaped the awards from a side that is devoid of any real flair or creativity. He has instilled an honest work rate and settled on a solid formation.
The fact remains Ireland are still unbeaten and their hopes of participating in South Africa 2010 lay very much in their own hands.
Of course I can’t end this debate without allowing Eamonn Dunphy to have a final word.
“When kids see Lionel Messi, Steven Gerrard or Ronaldo they want to go out in the park and do what they’ve seen the guys do the night before. Nobody wants to go out in the park in the morning and hit the ball 60 yards up in air”.
The young generation of Ireland may not be inspired by the long-ball playing style of the men in green in this qualifying campaign. But an appearance in South Africa would create heroes and once more install a sense of pride in the nation.
It’s not pretty but it has proven effective. The Italians await.