The defender, who was returned to action at Villa Park after an injury lay-off, felt Arsene Wenger’s men created enough openings to find the net but admitted the visitors lacked conviction in the final third.
“It’s strange because their [Aston Villa] results don’t reflect their performances,” said Gibbs.
“We saw them against Man United here, and they were in the lead for quite a lot of the game. We know it’s always difficult to come to Villa.
“I think it was more we lacked a little bit of conviction in the final third. We just have to be a bit more ruthless I think.
“You can see that we’re trying to be creative. I think in this game we had enough chances to score.”
Left-back Gibbs admitted his frustration at being sidelined in recent weeks and insists he is focused on staying fit as a hectic festive fixture schedule looms large.
“It’s frustrating [to get injured] after getting off to a good run,” he contined. “I’m back now. It was just a little blip for me. We’ve got a busy period coming up and I want to concentrate on staying fit.
“I’m happy to be back playing. Hopefully I can stay fit, get a run of games, get my match fitness and [get] back on track.”
ENHANCED ODDS: Get 10/1 on England to beat Italy