Mauricio Pochettino’s side edged into a first half lead on Thursday night thanks to Nacer Chadli’s emphatic penalty after full-back Ben Davies was fouled in the area.
However, the Serie A side levelled in the 59th minute when Federico Bernardeschi’s deflected shot beat Spurs goalkeeper Michel Vorm in Florence.
Mason, who was named captain in the absence of Hugo Lloris, took to Twitter after the stalemate to reflect on a special evening for the Tottenham youth graduate.
Very proud moment and an honour to captain the side tonight! An important away goal going into the game at the Lane next week! #COYS
— Ryan Mason (@RyanMason) February 18, 2016
Spurs face Fiorentina in the second leg of their Europa League tie at White Hart Lane next week.
The north London side are in second place in the Premier League table and just two points behind leaders Leicester City.
Tottenham host Crystal Palace in the FA Cup fifth round on Sunday afternoon.
MORE: The latest football news