The real Green Street at Upton Park

Upton parkExpect hefty fines, life bans and imprisonments, but will that solve the situation?

Upton park

One could be forgiven for watching, reading or even listening to the trouble which marred last night’s Carling Cup tie and confuse it with a scene from Lexi Alexander’s blockbuster film ‘Green Street’.

Maybe it could be mistaken for a deleted scene from the climax of the film when rival firms from West Ham United and Millwall clash. However there was no Elijah Wood getting his fists bloody this time. It was real life.

Before, during and after the game trouble ensued. It varied from pitch invasions, throwing of missiles such as bottles and even a stabbing. The clashes between Hammers and Lions fan marred a 3-1 victory after extra time for the home side.

The trouble started before the game even kicked off with rival ‘supporters’ clashing close to Upton Park. According to eye witnesses, fighting started around 6pm as fans made their way to the ground.

Inside the ground police and fans clashed. On both occasions when West Ham scored, home supporters invaded the pitch despite the best efforts of the stewards and officials.

Players pleaded with the intruders to vacate the pitch, with pictures showing Jack Collison begging fans to return to their seats, after a tragic week for the Welsh international.

The unrelenting violence continued after the game, with riot police on duty, to try and quell any trouble as thousands of fans left the stadium.

One thing is certain – the FA, the police, and both clubs will carrying out thorough investigations into the shocking scenes which ruined a good match for the real football fans in attendance.

Expect hefty fines, life bans and imprisonments, but will that solve the situation?

It does begs the question whether volatile derbies like West Ham United v Millwall where there has been a history of violence and in the past the authorities have failed to cope should be held behind closed doors.

A measure to ensure the safety of fans, players and officials.

The problem with life bans is it’s all well and good banning these thugs from attending the games, but they are still able to turn up before and after the game and initiate friction, adding fuel to a highly flammable situation.

Of course the proposal of playing highly charged games behind doors does punish the supporters to come to the stadium to enjoy football and steer clear of any trouble. But would it be for the greater good?

Having listened to the reaction of the real fans today they were understandably shaken. Local residents and shop owners were also rattled by the violence.

A 29-year-old man who runs a kebab shop in Green Street said: “All hell broke loose, it was very frightening. It’s not every day you see stuff like that.”

It could be argued that glamorous hooligan movies like ‘Green Street’ and ‘Football Factory’ portray such savagery at football games in an almost positive light. The films suggest that hooliganism is a way to earn respect of fellow thugs.

In Ireland, rival counties play each other weekly, with fierce rivalries that originated over a century ago. Croke Park can fill over 82,000 supporters. Trouble is unheard of.

Families mix together, discuss which side was better on the day, and are gracious in defeat. Maybe it is a cultural difference.

Ireland is a nation with a troubled past, and as a result it has resulted in the Irish holding a mutual respect for each other.

Of course it is only a very minute percentage of English football ‘fans’ that cause trouble, and it is unfair to tarnish every football supporter in Britain as a troublemaker.

Paul Scholes
Paul Scholes predicts Liverpool FC v Man United
Jurgen Klopp
Reporter: Liverpool FC boss Jurgen Klopp has asked about Brighton star Yves Bissouma
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Andy Cole predicts where Man United will finish this season
Frank Lampard
William Gallas urges Chelsea FC to sign Declan Rice from West Ham United
Paul Scholes
Paul Scholes tells Man United to sign Wesley Fofana from Leicester City
Paul Scholes
Paul Scholes predicts Liverpool FC v Man United
Jurgen Klopp
Reporter: Liverpool FC boss Jurgen Klopp has asked about Brighton star Yves Bissouma
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer
Andy Cole predicts where Man United will finish this season
Frank Lampard
William Gallas urges Chelsea FC to sign Declan Rice from West Ham United
Paul Scholes
Paul Scholes tells Man United to sign Wesley Fofana from Leicester City
Top 50 Muslim footballers: Arsenal, Chelsea FC, Liverpool FC and Man United stars feature
Top 50 Muslim footballers: Arsenal, Chelsea FC, Liverpool FC and Man United stars feature