Man City 1 Man United 0: Decisive derby fails to live up to the hype

Alex Sharp looks back at Monday's Manchester derby at the Etihad Stadium, when Roberto Mancini's City edged to victory

sir alex ferguson
Sir Alex Ferguson's side were undone by Vincent Kompany's header on Monday The Sport Review

sir alex ferguson

Unmissable! The biggest game in the Premier League’s history – the most important Manchester derby of all time. Monday night’s battle between Manchester’s United and City was tense but definitely failed to live up to the hype.

One of the most noticeable facets of the game was that Sir Alex Ferguson set his side out with a negative outlook. He knew a draw would suffice in the title race and tried to suffocate the force of Yaya Toure by crowding the midfield.

Wayne Rooney has been in red-hot form in recent months; his 13 goals means he has scored the most Premier League goals in 2012 – but he was left isolated by the United line-up at the Etihad.

Bizarrely, Ferguson left out Antonio Valencia, whose distribution is superb off the flanks and is direct. His replacement Nani was dismal on the right, failing to provide any service or meaningful efforts on target.

Ferguson also went for his big game favourite Park Ji-Sung in the middle – but he had not started in the league since January. Was he ready for such a pivotal tie? He failed to make an impact and never looked to hook up with a despairing Rooney.

The biggest drama came on the touchline, when Ferguson clashed with his counterpart Roberto Mancini. After the game Ferguson claimed: “He was badgering the referee the whole game, the fourth official and the linesman, and the minute I go out there…”

The fact that Ferguson was so easily riled suggests that he clearly sees Mancini’s men as a threat for the foreseeable future beyond this campaign – and he doesn’t like it.

City, on the other hand, were surprisingly comfortable, with Pablo Zabaleta nullifying any United threat, match-winner Vincent Kompany leading with an exemplary performance with Gareth Barry putting in an inspired display. City players grinded, showed more guile and penned in United.

Crucially, City next face Champions League-chasing Newcastle, who will be looking to bounce back from their horrific 4-0 loss to Wigan at the weekend.

The final day of the season throws up relegation battling QPR, who could prove a major stumbling block in the quest for City’s first league title since 1968.

Neither game will be easy for Mancini’s men, particularly with United’s “easier” fixtures of Swansea at home followed by Sunderland away. Surely United will go for broke in the last two games and play with more flair and desire than on Monday.

The fact that Manchester United, with such a weak team, have led the way in this turbulent title race is testament to an incredible manager. On Monday he just got it horribly wrong up against a superb City.

Michael Owen
Michael Owen predicts the winner of Chelsea FC v Tottenham
Roy Keane
‘By far the better team’: Roy Keane reacts to Chelsea FC’s draw with Tottenham
Gary Neville
Gary Neville reacts to late VAR drama in Liverpool FC’s 1-1 draw at Brighton
Michael Owen
Michael Owen predicts the winner of Arsenal v Wolves
Michael Owen
Michael Owen states his prediction for Southampton v Man United
Michael Owen
Michael Owen predicts the winner of Chelsea FC v Tottenham
Roy Keane
‘By far the better team’: Roy Keane reacts to Chelsea FC’s draw with Tottenham
Gary Neville
Gary Neville reacts to late VAR drama in Liverpool FC’s 1-1 draw at Brighton
Michael Owen
Michael Owen predicts the winner of Arsenal v Wolves
Michael Owen
Michael Owen states his prediction for Southampton v Man United
Top 50 Muslim footballers: Arsenal, Chelsea FC, Liverpool FC and Man United stars feature
Top 50 Muslim footballers: Arsenal, Chelsea FC, Liverpool FC and Man United stars feature